~~ Odyssey Episode Competition: Season 3 Best-of-the-Best ~~

Whit's wiping down the counter, Connie's mopping the floor, and the kids are sipping on their milkshakes. If you want to talk about Adventures in Odyssey the radio drama, this is the spot to do just that!
Post Reply
User avatar
Bob
Catspaw Rocks!
Posts: 705
Joined: September 2006
Location: The Metroplex
Gender:
Contact:
Contact Bob

Post by Bob »

Ballot #1
Malachi's Message, Pts. 1-3 - 14 Points
Clara - 14 Points
Exit - 11 Points (-1)
Connie, Pts. 1-2 - 5 Points (+1)
The Nemesis, Pts. 1-2 - 15 Points
For Whom The Wedding Bell Tolls, Pts. 1-3 - 17 Points
Life In The Third Person, Pts. 1-3 - 24 Points

Ballot #2
Waylaid In The Windy City, Pts. 1-2 - 1 Points (-1)
The Time Has Come - 16 Points
A Name, Not a Number, Pts. 1-2 - 25 Points
The Battle, Pts. 1-2 - 10 Points
The Perfect Witness, Pts. 1-3 - 23 Points (+1)
The Mortal Coil, Pts. 1-2 - 25 Points

"Waylaid in the Windy City", now facing elimination.
Top
User avatar
shadowdog
Still standing tall
Posts: 1361
Joined: October 2010
Location: Ohio

Post by shadowdog »

Ballot #1
Malachi's Message, Pts. 1-3 - 14 Points
Clara - 14 Points
Exit - 11 Points
Connie, Pts. 1-2 - 4 Points (-1)
The Nemesis, Pts. 1-2 - 15 Points
For Whom The Wedding Bell Tolls, Pts. 1-3 - 17 Points
Life In The Third Person, Pts. 1-3 - 25 Points (+1)

Ballot #2
Waylaid In The Windy City, Pts. 1-2 - 0 Points (-1)
The Time Has Come - 16 Points
A Name, Not a Number, Pts. 1-2 - 25 Points
The Battle, Pts. 1-2 - 10 Points
The Perfect Witness, Pts. 1-3 - 24 Points (+1)
The Mortal Coil, Pts. 1-2 - 25 Points

"Waylaid in the Windy City", now gone.

Who's next???
Top
User avatar
Bob
Catspaw Rocks!
Posts: 705
Joined: September 2006
Location: The Metroplex
Gender:
Contact:
Contact Bob

Post by Bob »

I'm not sure the vote total counts your vote (the one you posted before I did mine) -- we probably need to go back and adjust to count both of them.
Top
User avatar
shadowdog
Still standing tall
Posts: 1361
Joined: October 2010
Location: Ohio

Post by shadowdog »

Really??? I think they both add to 100. Double check.
Top
User avatar
Bob
Catspaw Rocks!
Posts: 705
Joined: September 2006
Location: The Metroplex
Gender:
Contact:
Contact Bob

Post by Bob »

Well, the thing isn't whether it adds to 100; the thing is whether it accounts for both of the -1s and +1s that were made.
Top
User avatar
shadowdog
Still standing tall
Posts: 1361
Joined: October 2010
Location: Ohio

Post by shadowdog »

I see where it went wrong....I think.

You added two to Connie and forgot to keep the point that I added to Life in the Third Person.

Go and check.


Am I right? This is confusing ;)
Top
User avatar
Bob
Catspaw Rocks!
Posts: 705
Joined: September 2006
Location: The Metroplex
Gender:
Contact:
Contact Bob

Post by Bob »

Well, I didn't forget it, so much as it didn't exist at the time I was posting it.

Lemme see.

Okay, I think here's what it looks like, all votes taken in consideration.

Ballot #1
Malachi's Message, Pts. 1-3 - 14 Points
Clara - 14 Points
Exit - 11 Points
Connie, Pts. 1-2 - 3 Points
The Nemesis, Pts. 1-2 - 15 Points
For Whom The Wedding Bell Tolls, Pts. 1-3 - 17 Points
Life In The Third Person, Pts. 1-3 - 26 Points

Ballot #2
The Time Has Come - 16 Points
A Name, Not a Number, Pts. 1-2 - 25 Points
The Battle, Pts. 1-2 - 9 Points
The Perfect Witness, Pts. 1-3 - 24 Points
The Mortal Coil, Pts. 1-2 - 25 Points
Top
User avatar
shadowdog
Still standing tall
Posts: 1361
Joined: October 2010
Location: Ohio

Post by shadowdog »

YAY! We got it fixed! :D

;)

Ballot #1
Malachi's Message, Pts. 1-3 - 14 Points
Clara - 14 Points
Exit - 11 Points
Connie, Pts. 1-2 - 2 Points (-1)
The Nemesis, Pts. 1-2 - 15 Points
For Whom The Wedding Bell Tolls, Pts. 1-3 - 17 Points
Life In The Third Person, Pts. 1-3 - 27 Points (+1)

Ballot #2
The Time Has Come - 16 Points
A Name, Not a Number, Pts. 1-2 - 25 Points
The Battle, Pts. 1-2 - 8 Points (-1)
The Perfect Witness, Pts. 1-3 - 25 Points (+1)
The Mortal Coil, Pts. 1-2 - 25 Points


Last post of day :D
Top
User avatar
American Eagle
Chief of Police
Posts: 11978
Joined: September 2008
Gender:

Post by American Eagle »

I'm not giving up on Exit, guys. ;) Even if I stand alone.

Ballot #1
Malachi's Message, Pts. 1-3 - 14 Points
Clara - 14 Points
Exit - 12 Points (+1)
Connie, Pts. 1-2 - 1 Points (-1)
The Nemesis, Pts. 1-2 - 15 Points
For Whom The Wedding Bell Tolls, Pts. 1-3 - 17 Points
Life In The Third Person, Pts. 1-3 - 27 Points

Ballot #2
The Time Has Come - 16 Points
A Name, Not a Number, Pts. 1-2 - 25 Points
The Battle, Pts. 1-2 - 7 Points (-1)
The Perfect Witness, Pts. 1-3 - 25 Points
The Mortal Coil, Pts. 1-2 - 26 Points (+1)
he/him | attorney | spartan | christian | bleeding heart type

Note: My past posts do not necessarily reflect my values. Many of them were made when I was young and (in retrospect) misguided. If you identify a post that expresses misinformation, prejudice, or anything harmful, please let me know.
Top
User avatar
Bob
Catspaw Rocks!
Posts: 705
Joined: September 2006
Location: The Metroplex
Gender:
Contact:
Contact Bob

Post by Bob »

With Connie facing elimination:

Ballot #1
Malachi's Message, Pts. 1-3 - 14 Points
Clara - 14 Points
Exit - 11 Points (-1)
Connie, Pts. 1-2 - 2 Points (+1)
The Nemesis, Pts. 1-2 - 15 Points
For Whom The Wedding Bell Tolls, Pts. 1-3 - 17 Points
Life In The Third Person, Pts. 1-3 - 27 Points

Ballot #2
The Time Has Come - 16 Points
A Name, Not a Number, Pts. 1-2 - 25 Points
The Battle, Pts. 1-2 - 6 Points (-1)
The Perfect Witness, Pts. 1-3 - 26 Points (+1)
The Mortal Coil, Pts. 1-2 - 26 Points
Last edited by Bob on Wed Jul 20, 2011 1:12 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Top
User avatar
American Eagle
Chief of Police
Posts: 11978
Joined: September 2008
Gender:

Post by American Eagle »

I simply do not understand.
he/him | attorney | spartan | christian | bleeding heart type

Note: My past posts do not necessarily reflect my values. Many of them were made when I was young and (in retrospect) misguided. If you identify a post that expresses misinformation, prejudice, or anything harmful, please let me know.
Top
User avatar
SoccerLOTR
If posts were pigs...
Posts: 2055
Joined: May 2005
Location: The Woodland Realm

Post by SoccerLOTR »

Connie has so much meaning in it...

Ballot #1
Malachi's Message, Pts. 1-3 - 14 Points
Clara - 14 Points
Exit - 11 Points
Connie, Pts. 1-2 - 2 Points
The Nemesis, Pts. 1-2 - 16 Points (+1)
For Whom The Wedding Bell Tolls, Pts. 1-3 - 17 Points
Life In The Third Person, Pts. 1-3 - 26 Points (-1)

Ballot #2
The Time Has Come - 16 Points
A Name, Not a Number, Pts. 1-2 - 26 Points (+1)
The Battle, Pts. 1-2 - 6 Points
The Perfect Witness, Pts. 1-3 - 25 Points
The Mortal Coil, Pts. 1-2 - 26 Points
Image
Image
It was good knowing you StrongNChrist; you taught me a lot. I'll meet you someday for real in God's presence.

Which Jesus do you follow? If Ephesians says to imitate Christ, why do you look so much like the world?~Todd Agnew

Do not be anxious about anything...~Phil 4:6-7

If more of us valued food, cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world.~Tolkien

Always vote for principle, though you may vote alone, and you may cherish the sweetest reflection that your vote is never lost.~J Adams

Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.~B Franklin

I died and became a Roman Soldier--It was rather distracting.~Rory (Dr.Who)
Top
User avatar
American Eagle
Chief of Police
Posts: 11978
Joined: September 2008
Gender:

Post by American Eagle »

Well, of course it does, but it's time to move on. Ballot #1 has seven episodes while #2 has only five. It's time for someone to get this game going...

Ballot #1
Malachi's Message, Pts. 1-3 - 14 Points
Clara - 14 Points
Exit - 12 Points (+1)
Connie, Pts. 1-2 - 1 Points (-1)
The Nemesis, Pts. 1-2 - 16 Points
For Whom The Wedding Bell Tolls, Pts. 1-3 - 17 Points
Life In The Third Person, Pts. 1-3 - 26 Points

Ballot #2
The Time Has Come - 16 Points
A Name, Not a Number, Pts. 1-2 - 26 Points
The Battle, Pts. 1-2 - 5 Points (-1)
The Perfect Witness, Pts. 1-3 - 25 Points
The Mortal Coil, Pts. 1-2 - 27 Points (+1)
he/him | attorney | spartan | christian | bleeding heart type

Note: My past posts do not necessarily reflect my values. Many of them were made when I was young and (in retrospect) misguided. If you identify a post that expresses misinformation, prejudice, or anything harmful, please let me know.
Top
User avatar
SoccerLOTR
If posts were pigs...
Posts: 2055
Joined: May 2005
Location: The Woodland Realm

Post by SoccerLOTR »

So you're all for the action/adventure over Connie, but then you forsake all the action/adventure on the next ballot to vote for The Mortal Coil?

Ballot #1
Malachi's Message, Pts. 1-3 - 15 Points (+1)
Clara - 14 Points
Exit - 12 Points
Connie, Pts. 1-2 - 1 Points
The Nemesis, Pts. 1-2 - 16 Points
For Whom The Wedding Bell Tolls, Pts. 1-3 - 17 Points
Life In The Third Person, Pts. 1-3 - 25 Points (-1)

Ballot #2
The Time Has Come - 16 Points
A Name, Not a Number, Pts. 1-2 - 27 Points (+1)
The Battle, Pts. 1-2 - 5 Points
The Perfect Witness, Pts. 1-3 - 24 Points (-1)
The Mortal Coil, Pts. 1-2 - 27 Points
Image
Image
It was good knowing you StrongNChrist; you taught me a lot. I'll meet you someday for real in God's presence.

Which Jesus do you follow? If Ephesians says to imitate Christ, why do you look so much like the world?~Todd Agnew

Do not be anxious about anything...~Phil 4:6-7

If more of us valued food, cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world.~Tolkien

Always vote for principle, though you may vote alone, and you may cherish the sweetest reflection that your vote is never lost.~J Adams

Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.~B Franklin

I died and became a Roman Soldier--It was rather distracting.~Rory (Dr.Who)
Top
User avatar
American Eagle
Chief of Police
Posts: 11978
Joined: September 2008
Gender:

Post by American Eagle »

SoccerLOTR wrote:So you're all for the action/adventure over Connie, but then you forsake all the action/adventure on the next ballot to vote for The Mortal Coil?
Yes, and if people were voting down Clara, I would do my best to save it. I think Clara, Exit and The Mortal Coil are the best episodes in this game (along with Aloha, Oy! and Gone..., which aren't here). I don't think Connie is quite as good as those.

I'm fine with you guys trying to keep Connie just above 0... as long as you aren't just doing it for the lulz.
he/him | attorney | spartan | christian | bleeding heart type

Note: My past posts do not necessarily reflect my values. Many of them were made when I was young and (in retrospect) misguided. If you identify a post that expresses misinformation, prejudice, or anything harmful, please let me know.
Top
User avatar
Bob
Catspaw Rocks!
Posts: 705
Joined: September 2006
Location: The Metroplex
Gender:
Contact:
Contact Bob

Post by Bob »

Vote #1, 7/21/2011.

Well, the way I see it, it's a generic (and in my mind overrated) action/adventure episode, that uses every cliche in the book (kidnapped damsel in distress, the villains attempting to taking over the world with mind control, the least likely guy having to bail everyone out, etc., etc., etc.) that has limited application to someone's life against the episode two-parter that brought the show's all-time #2 character to salvation, and shows the circumstances that helped it happen.

I would personally rank Malachi's Message, Clara, Connie, For Whom The Wedding Bell Tolls, Life, TTHC, TPW, and The Mortal Coil all above "Exit" -- and I'd consider giving the older adventure episodes higher ratings too, just because their outcomes weren't so incredibly pre-determined.

In "The Nemesis", I was surprised when Tom's barn actually burned down, nearly killing him and his horses, and when Blackgaard got his license. In "The Battle", I was surprised when Lucy ran into the room and got fried by a power surge. In "A Name, Not a Number" I was surprised when Blackgaard turned out to be alive after all of the previous drama.

I was *not* surprised that Novacom failed to take over the world in "Exit". The only remotely surprising thing that happened was that they had to destroy the Imagination Station -- which is kind of a bummer, but not really since we all know Whit can just build a newer and better one. What kind of a loss is it when the only thing that goes wrong can be easily fixed?

Ballot #1
Malachi's Message, Pts. 1-3 - 15 Points
Clara - 14 Points
Exit - 11 Points (-1)
Connie, Pts. 1-2 - 2 Points (+1)
The Nemesis, Pts. 1-2 - 16 Points
For Whom The Wedding Bell Tolls, Pts. 1-3 - 17 Points
Life In The Third Person, Pts. 1-3 - 25 Points

Ballot #2
The Time Has Come - 16 Points
A Name, Not a Number, Pts. 1-2 - 27 Points
The Battle, Pts. 1-2 - 4 Points (-1)
The Perfect Witness, Pts. 1-3 - 25 Points (+1)
The Mortal Coil, Pts. 1-2 - 27 Points

Also: The numbers in Ballot #2 don't add up to 100. I suspect it's because of pre-"solution" "The Battle" votes, but I can't work out why right now... all I can say is that this is horribly frustrating and makes me wish we had an automated process to handle this.
Top
User avatar
himi34
Hexadecimal teenager
Posts: 20
Joined: July 2011

Post by himi34 »

Ballot #1
Malachi's Message, Pts. 1-3 - 14 Points (-1)
Clara - 15 Points (+1)
Exit - 11 Points
Connie, Pts. 1-2 - 2 Points
The Nemesis, Pts. 1-2 - 16 Points
For Whom The Wedding Bell Tolls, Pts. 1-3 - 17 Points
Life In The Third Person, Pts. 1-3 - 25 Points

Ballot #2
The Time Has Come - 15 Points 9(-1)
A Name, Not a Number, Pts. 1-2 - 28 Points (+1)
The Battle, Pts. 1-2 - 4 Points
The Perfect Witness, Pts. 1-3 - 25 Points
The Mortal Coil, Pts. 1-2 - 27 Points
Top
User avatar
American Eagle
Chief of Police
Posts: 11978
Joined: September 2008
Gender:

Post by American Eagle »

Ballot #1
Malachi's Message, Pts. 1-3 - 13 Points (-1)
Clara - 15 Points
Exit - 12 Points (+1)
Connie, Pts. 1-2 - 2 Points
The Nemesis, Pts. 1-2 - 16 Points
For Whom The Wedding Bell Tolls, Pts. 1-3 - 17 Points
Life In The Third Person, Pts. 1-3 - 25 Points

Ballot #2
The Time Has Come - 15 Points
A Name, Not a Number, Pts. 1-2 - 28 Points
The Battle, Pts. 1-2 - 3 Points (-1)
The Perfect Witness, Pts. 1-3 - 25 Points
The Mortal Coil, Pts. 1-2 - 28 Points (+1)
he/him | attorney | spartan | christian | bleeding heart type

Note: My past posts do not necessarily reflect my values. Many of them were made when I was young and (in retrospect) misguided. If you identify a post that expresses misinformation, prejudice, or anything harmful, please let me know.
Top
User avatar
Bob
Catspaw Rocks!
Posts: 705
Joined: September 2006
Location: The Metroplex
Gender:
Contact:
Contact Bob

Post by Bob »

Ballot #1
Malachi's Message, Pts. 1-3 - 13 Points
Clara - 15 Points
Exit - 12 Points
Connie, Pts. 1-2 - 3 Points (+1)
The Nemesis, Pts. 1-2 - 15 Points (-1)
For Whom The Wedding Bell Tolls, Pts. 1-3 - 17 Points
Life In The Third Person, Pts. 1-3 - 25 Points

Ballot #2
The Time Has Come - 16 Points (+1)
A Name, Not a Number, Pts. 1-2 - 28 Points
The Battle, Pts. 1-2 - 2 Points (-1)
The Perfect Witness, Pts. 1-3 - 25 Points
The Mortal Coil, Pts. 1-2 - 28 Points
Top
User avatar
SoccerLOTR
If posts were pigs...
Posts: 2055
Joined: May 2005
Location: The Woodland Realm

Post by SoccerLOTR »

Bob, thank you for the detailed explanation of why some of the episodes are better than others...

Ballot #1
Malachi's Message, Pts. 1-3 - 13 Points
Clara - 15 Points
Exit - 12 Points
Connie, Pts. 1-2 - 3 Points
The Nemesis, Pts. 1-2 - 16 Points (+1)
For Whom The Wedding Bell Tolls, Pts. 1-3 - 17 Points
Life In The Third Person, Pts. 1-3 - 24 Points (-1)

Ballot #2
The Time Has Come - 16 Points
A Name, Not a Number, Pts. 1-2 - 29 Points (+1)
The Battle, Pts. 1-2 - 2 Points
The Perfect Witness, Pts. 1-3 - 24 Points (-1)
The Mortal Coil, Pts. 1-2 - 28 Points
Image
Image
It was good knowing you StrongNChrist; you taught me a lot. I'll meet you someday for real in God's presence.

Which Jesus do you follow? If Ephesians says to imitate Christ, why do you look so much like the world?~Todd Agnew

Do not be anxious about anything...~Phil 4:6-7

If more of us valued food, cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world.~Tolkien

Always vote for principle, though you may vote alone, and you may cherish the sweetest reflection that your vote is never lost.~J Adams

Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.~B Franklin

I died and became a Roman Soldier--It was rather distracting.~Rory (Dr.Who)
Top
Post Reply

Return to “Whit's End”