I read through all of these, and though it's been years since I read the book I have an answer for nearly every one (some taken from the book I hold in my hand now.
).
1. Edmund never wanted to enlist in the Army
Nothing for this, aside from what I said in the other thread. It's better then being with Eustace.
2. They were pulled into the picture; their room didn't flood over with water.
Page 7-8. Waves do come out of the picture and the room does get flooded. By the time they all surface they're in Narnia.
3. Aslan was not on the Dawn Treader when Edmund, Eustace, and Lucy come aboard.
He shows up in the magician's house after Lucy reads through the book on page 131.
4. There was no water mermaid in the water when they are on the Dawn Treader till the very end when they are almost to the world's end.
So then that was a clip from when they were at the world's end. =P
5. They were not brought back to Narnia to be 'tested'.
No, they were not, from what I can remember. That part's gonna be interesting.
6. The White Witch NEVER comes back in human/spirit form or any form for that matter. She is dead.
What about the island where bad dreams come true? In the FotF CD versions they added the witch's cackle. Edmund would probably have a hidden fear of her after she nearly stabbed him through the heart.
7. When Lucy goes through the magic book, snow doesn't cover the room.
Page 129. "...How to call up (or prevent) wind, fog,
snow, sleet, or rain..." So Lucy must read the spell aloud. *shrugs*
8. The woman that Prince Caspian ends up marrying doesn't glow like a lighting bug.
On page 176, when the old star comes out, he is glowing. So I guess they took that and decided to make her glow also to get the star point across.
9. Edmund doesn't have a sword that glows either.
Haha. That will be funny. Sting, anyone?
10. The girl that Prince Caspian marries does not become a ball and shoot up into the sky like a reverse shooting star.
They could be skipping ahead in the old star's life and show him becoming a star again.
11. I never remembered there being a fighting scene with Lucy hold a bow and arrow. (correct me if I'm wrong)
That's probably in the scene with the sea serpent. Lucy obviously doesn't do any manly work like trying to shove the serpent's body off the deck, so she might've been shooting arrows at it to distract it.
12. And I don't remember them exactly ever returning 'for a reason'. I mean I though Aslan just brought them to help Caspian
.
Page 216. "I am. But I have another name. You must learn to know me by that name.
This was the very reason why you were brought to Narnia, that by knowing me here for a little, you may know me better there." -Aslan to Edmund and Lucy after telling them on the previous page they can't come back.
13. They didn't even show how Eustace becomes a dragon
Who says they won't in the actual movie? =P They can only fit so much in two minutes and ten seconds.
14. Peter and Susan were barely ever mentioned in the Voyage of the Dawn Treader book let alone they were never in Narnia in this story. At the end of Prince Caspian Aslan tells them they will NEVER EVER return to Narnia.
Lucy sees them both in the magical book, I think.
Definately Susan (I just checked, page 130) with the part about the beauty spell, but I don't know about Peter. *shrugs*
So no, the movie isn't necessarily going to bomb.
All we can see know is two minutes out of about 120. There's a hecka lot more to be seen, don't worry.
