Page 5 of 7

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Mon Jul 18, 2011 2:53 pm
by Musical Shutterbug
Taps wrote:*comes in and whispers* I think Steel H and IDANCE are the mafia * disappears*
Uh, who's Steel?

I can't be partners with someone that I don't know :noway:
AIOluver wrote:I vote SWA

Vote: SWA
It would be nice if you could list a reason :anxious:


I am going to make this crystal clear for everyone. The more you protest, the more you look guilty. This is why SWA now looks very, very guilty.
Stop Wooton' Around wrote:Okay like people have pointed out that the 1st vote is just a guess, but I was thinking Maggots are kinda related to Bookworms. I know he doesn't seem to be the type to come up with a "stupid" (my apologizes) kill like maggots in the eyes but maybe that was a cover?
Interesting idea....however, I believe bookworm is too intelligent to think of something so absurd :- You can't look at the way people are behaving just in this game, you have to consider their characters as ToOers in general.

I need to think a little more before casting a vote.

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Mon Jul 18, 2011 2:55 pm
by bookworm
IDANCE4JESUS wrote:I believe bookworm is too intelligent to think of something so absurd :- You can't look at the way people are behaving just in this game, you have to consider their characters as ToOers in general.
I appreciate that. ;)
Doing something out of character like that is a ploy worthy of my cunning, in theory, but using that particular kill method to do it is quite far fetched for me. (No offense to whoever did it, it’s just not me.)

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Mon Jul 18, 2011 2:56 pm
by Musical Shutterbug
Well, it's true :p

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Mon Jul 18, 2011 3:00 pm
by bookworm
Is this still the current player list Monty?
Monty wrote:KF: Townie
AIOluver
Shadowdog
Parker Family
Taps: Cop
Bookworm
Yanny: Townie
IDANCE4JESUS
Stop Wooton' Around

Kill Key:
Name=Killed by mafia
Name=Lynched
Name=Removed from game for missing two daytime votes.[/spoiler]

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Mon Jul 18, 2011 3:01 pm
by Stop Wooton' Around
Okay kill me and have fun!

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Mon Jul 18, 2011 3:03 pm
by bookworm
Well if you have a decent defense please speak it now. We certainly don’t want to needlessly kill another Town. We’re getting down to the wire here.

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Mon Jul 18, 2011 3:03 pm
by Musical Shutterbug
After much consideration, well, five minutes worth anyways :p
...I have decided.

VOTE: SWA

Yes, if you have a reasonable explanation why we should not vote for you, please say so.

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Mon Jul 18, 2011 3:06 pm
by Stop Wooton' Around
I could make up one but that would be dishonest! I'm not going to lie. Sorry fellow Mafia member. Its not worth lying over! I hope you can still win!

O and I came up with that ridiculous kill! It was a great cover and I got taps killed by doing so! :lol: Did you notice I made fun of it!
That was just about the dumbest way to kill somebody, I've ever seen. Get real, can that even happen? Does this not seem like something Taps would do?

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Mon Jul 18, 2011 3:06 pm
by Musical Shutterbug
He admits that he's the mafia?!

Well, that was easy \:D/

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Mon Jul 18, 2011 3:08 pm
by bookworm
This is quite a development.
*hopes this is real, otherwise it throws a whole new wrench in the works*

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Mon Jul 18, 2011 3:08 pm
by Musical Shutterbug
No kidding.

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Mon Jul 18, 2011 3:10 pm
by bookworm
Let’s do a plea deal. If you tell us who the other Mafia is you’ll get off with life imprisonment.

(I’m kidding of course. That would ruin the integrity of the game.)

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Mon Jul 18, 2011 3:14 pm
by Musical Shutterbug
...but it would be fun \:D/

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Mon Jul 18, 2011 3:14 pm
by bookworm
Stop Wooton' Around wrote:O and I came up with that ridiculous kill! It was a great cover and I got taps killed by doing so! :lol: Did you notice I made fun of it!
That was just about the dumbest way to kill somebody, I've ever seen. Get real, can that even happen? Does this not seem like something Taps would do?
That was actually when I began suspecting you. You were the first to bash it rather than question it. Made it seem too obvious that it wasn’t yours. I did also suspect Taps though, so I went with that first. So it worked for a while, I’ll give you that.

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Mon Jul 18, 2011 6:52 pm
by shadowdog
Hmmmmm.....who to vote for....... ;)

Vote: SWA


It's really no fun when a mafia says he's the mafia. :)

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Mon Jul 18, 2011 9:18 pm
by Stop Wooton' Around
Okay, I'm going to die. But what was I supposed to do after I questioned Bookworm like that. I had to admit I can't just sit there and lie, I'm not that type. All I can say is fellow Mafia member, if you haven't voted against me already, do so.

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Tue Jul 19, 2011 12:29 pm
by bookworm
Stop Wooton' Around wrote:All I can say is fellow Mafia member, if you haven't voted against me already, do so.
Very good thinking. Since you’re getting killed whatever happens, they should vote the same way so no one sticks out.
You aren’t a bad player, you’re just too honest for your own good. ;)
Stop Wooton' Around wrote:But what was I supposed to do after I questioned Bookworm like that.
Probably exactly what you did. It wasn’t your fault, you made a good effort. I already suspected you, remember. I was already going to vote for you this round before you said that.

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Tue Jul 19, 2011 6:18 pm
by Taps
Stop Wooton' Around wrote:I could make up one but that would be dishonest! I'm not going to lie. Sorry fellow Mafia member. Its not worth lying over! I hope you can still win!

O and I came up with that ridiculous kill! It was a great cover and I got taps killed by doing so! :lol: Did you notice I made fun of it!
That was just about the dumbest way to kill somebody, I've ever seen. Get real, can that even happen? Does this not seem like something Taps would do?

Told you :( I was the victim of a good playing Mafia :(

actually you killed Yanny to because IDANCE4JESUS pegged both me and him because of zat sentence.

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Wed Jul 20, 2011 8:56 pm
by Stop Wooton' Around
bookworm wrote:
Stop Wooton' Around wrote:All I can say is fellow Mafia member, if you haven't voted against me already, do so.
Very good thinking. Since you’re getting killed whatever happens, they should vote the same way so no one sticks out.
You aren’t a bad player, you’re just too honest for your own good. ;)
Stop Wooton' Around wrote:But what was I supposed to do after I questioned Bookworm like that.
Probably exactly what you did. It wasn’t your fault, you made a good effort. I already suspected you, remember. I was already going to vote for you this round before you said that.
Thank you for your comment! I just couldn't lie like that and to be honest I did come up with that stupid kill but it was actually not planned as a trick. We had to give a kill in a hurry so I just throw that in there and they took it. So I just turned it around to make Taps look guilty. It worked out okay but its kinda embarrassing that I didn't plan that and that was my honest to goodness kill! :oops:

Re: Mafia: Version 5. ***NEW ROLES!!!***

Posted: Thu Jul 21, 2011 11:18 am
by bookworm
But that’s even more impressive, that you were able to use it to divert suspicion after the fact and unplanned. :yes: