675: A Thankstaking Story

Review it!

Archived reviews of Adventures in Odyssey episodes!

What is your rating?

5 stars - will be a favorite for years to come
6
17%
4 stars - well done and enjoyable
14
40%
3 stars - average...
6
17%
2 stars - only a few redeeming qualities
7
20%
1 star - I never want to hear this episode again
2
6%
 
Total votes: 35

User avatar
Laura Ingalls
Half Pint
Half Pint
Posts: 11491
Joined: April 2005
Location: Suburbia

675: A Thankstaking Story

Post by Laura Ingalls »

What did you think of today's episode? \:D/ I will give my review after I listen to it in 15 minutes. ;)
The Lord is not slow about His promise, as some count slowness, but is patient toward you, not wishing for any to perish, but for all to come to repentance.
User avatar
Peachey Keen
Smile for the camera
Posts: 1198
Joined: July 2008
Location: Where The Wind Comes Sweeping Down The Plain
Gender:

Post by Peachey Keen »

You can listen to it hear! :D
User avatar
Marvin D.
i haz xpirenancee!!1
Posts: 19545
Joined: November 2009
Location: Amsterdam
Contact:

Post by Marvin D. »

Oh, snap, Laura beat me to it. :(

I'll review after listening. ;)
"I still see Marvin as a newbie that is just as cool as an oldie." --snubs

Most Sarcastic Poster | Most Likely To Be Eaten By a Dinosaur and Smote by God |
Biggest Joker and Grammar Nazi | Best Writer
User avatar
Laura Ingalls
Half Pint
Half Pint
Posts: 11491
Joined: April 2005
Location: Suburbia

Post by Laura Ingalls »

Peachey Keen wrote:You can listen to it hear! :D
Thanks, PK! :D

I really liked this one! It was just an enjoyable holiday spoof, and I liked the addition of the songs as well. \:D/ There was a little reference to I Love Lucy in there with the "You have some 'splainin to do!" line. :lol: I'm glad Katrina was at least talked about, if not heard.

All in all, this was 4/5 stars, and I would like to listen to it again.
The Lord is not slow about His promise, as some count slowness, but is patient toward you, not wishing for any to perish, but for all to come to repentance.
User avatar
Jimmy Barclay Fan
Classic
Posts: 661
Joined: April 2005
Location: Southeast USA

Post by Jimmy Barclay Fan »

I really enjoyed it. It was the 2nd Thanksgiving episode to spoof a Christmas story and change it. It was enjoyable and fun and a little silly.
Uncle Wally sounded like he was doing a Cliff from Cheers imitation.
Image


I am a big fan of AIO, but I am not Jave Griffin or have ever been on AIO. I am just a huge fan of AIO and Jimmy Barclay. I love Odyssey, and Jimmy rules.
User avatar
Peachey Keen
Smile for the camera
Posts: 1198
Joined: July 2008
Location: Where The Wind Comes Sweeping Down The Plain
Gender:

Post by Peachey Keen »

After having my hopes dashed about the eps which I thought would be the best, but turned out differently, I was really happy when I heard this episode.

All the characters (Odyssey characters) were great and not a single one was annoying. The acting was up to par and so was the music.
I loved it that AIO again spoofed a Christmas story and made it into a Thanksgiving story. I love listening to it again cause there's a lot of things you catch later on, like "God is faithful 100%" from Horton Hears a Who, "An elephant's faithful %100." :D

Dave Arnold is a really great writer. He's been hiding his talent all these years by doing sound design. Way to go Dave!

This has to be my favorite show of this season. 5 out of 5 for me.
User avatar
DanP740
Trank Tank Driver
Trank Tank Driver
Posts: 6764
Joined: April 2005
Location: In my chair
Contact:

Post by DanP740 »

This episode just didn't catch and hold my attention, so I kind of tuned out during parts, so later on I was a little lost...
3/5

EDIT: Katrina finally being mentioned was a plus, though...

(the little things in the poll after the rating number like "only a few redeeming qualities" slightly annoy me because it makes me want to rate it with the option that says what I thought, rather than my rating...)
Image
StrongNChrist 1991-2011
Use the chatroom! It's been active for a year, and most of you are missing it.
"Every time I start banging rocks together to make a beat, I feel all guilty and I need to repent for my sinful ways. :(" - Jelly
"I actually want to see this happen... the controversy would be legendary. :o" - American Eagle
":hilarious: This ladies and gentlemen is the founding of: 'The Awkward Club!'" - Steve
"Happy birthday, big Mercy! \:D/ \:D/" - Whitty Whit
I wasn't yelling. I was talking with vehemence.
Dave
Classic
Posts: 656
Joined: April 2005
Contact:

Post by Dave »

"Earlier this week I was listening to a wonderful Thanksgiving show from one of my favorite radio dramas. It was funny, heart-warming, and the occasional moment even brought tears to my eyes. I was entranced from beginning to end, wrapped up in the drama and loving how well-written the characters were.

The only problem for this review is that the show wasn't 'A Thankstaking Story,'..."

Read the rest of my review here.
User avatar
Bones
Lurker
Posts: 6
Joined: May 2010

Post by Bones »

I thought that it was good!
I listened to the show this morning with my sister. We both enjoyed it a lot.
I thought it was a funny and light-hearted spoof. I like all the characters in this one.
I gave it a 5/5
31899
No way I broke the window
Posts: 3613
Joined: February 2009
Location: how come you don't want me now

Post by 31899 »

I listened to it on the weekend of Canadian Thanksgiving and I thought it was rather tacky. I also thought that it is a bit odd that Whit's End Doesn't have a fire place. I also thought it was rather unfair to the casual listener to throw in the Captain Absolutely when they never aired The Truth Chronicles (to my knowledge.) The episode also seemed like patchwork writing that started out as one thing but ended as something completely differently from first draft to final draft. 2/5

31899
User avatar
Laura Ingalls
Half Pint
Half Pint
Posts: 11491
Joined: April 2005
Location: Suburbia

Post by Laura Ingalls »

Captain Absolutely? :-k I didn't hear him make any appearance...did I miss something?
The Lord is not slow about His promise, as some count slowness, but is patient toward you, not wishing for any to perish, but for all to come to repentance.
31899
No way I broke the window
Posts: 3613
Joined: February 2009
Location: how come you don't want me now

Post by 31899 »

Maybe I got my episodes mixed up... I'll go relisten...

Edit: so I relistened to part of it and this was the episode with the "The Grinch" type episode, so I'm not sure where I got Captain absolutely from :oops:

Episode Review Revised

Another one of AIO use someone else's idea and twist it for their own purpose, but I found it rather interesting. I found it different that they had multiple villains and the moral was right their in front of you (unlike Mystery of the Clock Tower. This episode seemed almost like a kids radio adventure, and I'm sort of sad it wasn't. (It seems like one of the adventures Mandy would have produced)

31899
User avatar
jennifertwt
Catspaw Rocks!
Posts: 790
Joined: April 2008
Location: Stockholm, Sweden

Post by jennifertwt »

This was one of my last hopes for redeeming this album after the disappointment of The Mystery of the Clock Tower. In reading some of the above reviews, I don't think we listened to the same episode. I found the voices very irritating. The 'story' hard to follow. It seemed like Lights out At Whits End meets The Grinch. I like both of those, strangely enough, just not together.

By contrast, I LOVED A Thanksgiving Carol which was well-done, interesting, and one of my all time favorites.

I'm beginning to be less enthused about getting *Album 52 any time soon. If Album 53 does not redeem the 're-launch'. I may give up and stick with my Album 1-50 collection and call it done.

Take Two: after having listened to it a second time with my swedish husband, who doesn't have all the emotional attachment to 'thanskgiving' that Americans do, he said it was silly but not terrible. I guess I have to agree. I did enjoy Eugene's song at the end and Whit's speech about celebrating thanksgiving no matter where you are. So, I guess I could up grade my vote to a '2'.
Last edited by jennifertwt on Sun Nov 28, 2010 12:12 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Jennifer Lundgren
Stockholm, Sweden
User avatar
Marvin D.
i haz xpirenancee!!1
Posts: 19545
Joined: November 2009
Location: Amsterdam
Contact:

Post by Marvin D. »

This episode was a fairly enjoyable one. I especially enjoyed all the music (as, I have mentioned before, I have a bias towards all musicals). Connie seemed like Connie again in the beginning, and Whit played the ordinary one I was used to. Jay seemed different in this episode, as in his voice quality and the way he talked. The episode was slightly...cheesy, but all in all good. The moral was one of the easier ones to expect, as what to be thankful for. I wish there could be episodes with a different sort of moral (not just limited to AIO). However, it was still nice. The girl (the one played by Connie) seemed a little too sweet at times...maybe that's just me? But, all in all, it was a good episode. I'd give it 7/10.
"I still see Marvin as a newbie that is just as cool as an oldie." --snubs

Most Sarcastic Poster | Most Likely To Be Eaten By a Dinosaur and Smote by God |
Biggest Joker and Grammar Nazi | Best Writer
User avatar
Mark Prescott
Still standing tall
Posts: 1349
Joined: March 2010

Post by Mark Prescott »

Am I the only one who didn't like this episode? I thought it was alright. It would have been better if they wouldhave taken all of the songs out. Most of them, I couldn't understand what they were sining. I didn't like the the Grinch parody. I thought that they might have been better off coming up with their own plot. On the other hand, it was nice to hear the mention of Katrina again, and also, I liked How they all got snowed in at Whit's end. Once again, my high hopes for this Album 52 episode was dashed to smitherines. I give this episode a 2/5.
~Mark Prescott~
User avatar
Bennett
Someone's favorite
Posts: 1637
Joined: April 2005

Post by Bennett »

My review of today's show can be found here:

http://aio-thechangingtimes.blogspot.co ... story.html
User avatar
Dr. Watson
Be positive!
Posts: 5568
Joined: April 2005
Location: 221B Baker Street

Post by Dr. Watson »

A 3 star bonus gets added to any episode with Eugene's ukelele. \:D/ That said, I rated it a "4". :anxious:
User avatar
Dallas R.
My posts are revolutionary
Posts: 403
Joined: January 2009
Location: Wisconsin

Post by Dallas R. »

I'm surprised at how well this episode is being rated in the polls. I've actually started enjoying several of the episodes this season, and I've thought that's it's been nice to have some classic Odyssey episodes back. That said, I thought this episode was a pretty big disappointment. It might even be my least favorite on the album so far. I've never really been fan of the episodes where they tell stories in this fashion where we hear it come to life, sort of like they do in "Black Clouds" It seems a little cheesy, and I think it would work better as a kids radio episode. The Grinch spinoff was clever, but could have been done with a much funnier script that made a little more sense. It sort of felt like a Truth Chronicles episode. In redeeming qualities, each actor played their character well, but it took me a long time to figure out who the kid was. Eugene on the Ukulele was a nice added bonus, and the first reference to Katrina since the hiatus was nice as well. I'd be willing to bet post-hiatus fans of the show will now be like "What? Eugene is married?" Overall, I think I'd rate it a 2.5. I think the rating system should be rated in ten stars. I'm always wanting to give episodes half stars.
Katrina Meltsner talking to Katrina Shanks Video
(Pamela Hayden and Audrey Wasilewski face-off)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sDHyEphRM4g

Yep. Using my signature for a shameless plug. But trust me. If I can be so arrogant, I think it'll be worth your time.
User avatar
Bennett
Someone's favorite
Posts: 1637
Joined: April 2005

Post by Bennett »

Dallas R. wrote:I'm surprised at how well this episode is being rated in the polls.
I just finished comparing this episode to the rest of the season (and I went back and updated past episodes as well). "A Thankstaking Story" is currently the third lowest rated episode of the season:

http://aio-thechangingtimes.blogspot.co ... verys.html

So, not exactly the fan favorite that it was hyped up to be, that's for sure. And like you, I had high expectations, and expected this episode to be a new classic show. It isn't. But I think, at least the cut version, is still a very decent episode. I think people will warm up to this one in the future.
User avatar
Shennifer
Random sister
Random sister
Posts: 5774
Joined: June 2009
Location: norcal
Contact:

Post by Shennifer »

It was a good episode, in my opinion, but I was a bit distracted listening to all the details of the story, however I enjoyed it all the same. Nice to hear Eugene mention Katrina and also I was more used to Andre's voice this time. 4/5
Image

Till the end of the line.
Post Reply